Comments on: POLY & BARK Essex 89” Full-Grain Italian Leather Sofa –

By: Es Okay

Es Okay — Sat, 28 Mar 2026 09:26:53 +0000

Comfortable and Beautiful
We purchased two of these couches to replace 10 year old fabric sofas. The delivery was quick with minimal packaging (just the box with no pallet). The only assembly was attaching the legs.Pros: feels deeper than other sofas as there are no back cushions or rolled side arms, low back helps the room to feel larger, color is beautiful and rich and not as orange as a leather couch we purchased from a big-box warehouse store.Cons: low back and lack of back cushions means it is NOT as cushy as other sofas. We purposely bought these sofas because they are large but streamlined in a tight fitting area. We typically have 8+ teenagers at our house every weekend, and our son said he felt like 4 across was fine if they were comfortable sitting that close (not possible on our previous sofa of the same length). HOWEVER. The lack of back cushion and side cushions means the space is ample but it isn’t super cozy feeling. Throw pillows and a quilt thrown behind my back helped. Also, they were rather stiff for the first month. Again, great sofas, just not a cozy sofa. They also slide all over our wood. We got some sticky grippers for the legs which helps.They scratch easily. I’ve purchased leather conditioner which I am hoping helps since we regularly have a wood burning fireplace going all winter and we have very hot summers with lots of light in this room.I wanted to note that these couches went on a deep sale the day they were delivered. Amazon does NOT price match. So be aware that when buying two, you might want to watch the price changes because you can easily get these at 50% of the sticker price. I also didn’t realize we have a brick and mortar Poly and Bark store just 90 minutes from us and I regret not going to see them in person first (my sister did and got a different model that is much more comfortable).Overall, five stars, because they fit our purpose. I wish they were cozier, but then they would not be as deep or low line and wouldn’t fit our purpose in this small room. I would purchase again but not at the full price.

By: Joey

Joey — Sat, 28 Mar 2026 09:26:53 +0000

Amazing couch!
Fabulous in every respect. Make sure to purchase the deluxe in room delivery and assembly. While the assembly is easy, the product arrives full size and is unwieldy. It requires at least two people to move it and a great deal of clearance to navigate it.Cushions are a bit firm, but very comfortable. Leather is of high quality, stitching is solid and attractive. I would order again from poly and bark without hesitation.

By: Sshah_CHI41

Sshah_CHI41 — Sat, 28 Mar 2026 09:26:53 +0000

Stunning & Comfy
Beautiful, well crafted sofa. The leather is thick and high quality. Assembly took 10min. Sofa was packed very well and all the parts were there. The sofa is very well built, no issues there. The sit is a tad firm but I would assume it will get softer once broken in. I did have to condition/ oil the leather as it was pretty dry out of the box. It took about 30min with some leather conditioner. Otherwise fantastic sofa. Wish it was a little less expensive but I’m satisfied. The only concern I have is the warranty after the 1 yr mfg warranty. Not sure how much I trust the sellers warranty. You will not get an extended warranty from Poly and Bark, I called them to confirm.

By: Kelly

Kelly — Sat, 28 Mar 2026 09:26:53 +0000

Beautiful But Has a LOW Back!
Instructions manual can be found under cushions. Cushions have leather on one side, fabric on other. The back portion of couch is lower than normal and width is decent enough to fully and comfortably lay down. Love the leather smell! HAVE MONETARY TIP PREPARED FOR DELIVERER because they will make a huge fuss about bringing box into house. Also, ensure to purchase leather cleaner for maintainance. Seats feel firm; not too soft, not too hard. Lastly, you WILL need two people to flip couch over once legs are in place.

By: Stefani Buhajla

Stefani Buhajla — Sat, 28 Mar 2026 09:26:53 +0000

Better than expected
Shipping speed and coordination was horrendous. When it did finally get here, I was pleasantly surprised.Sofa is beautiful and the leather looks great. Some reviewers mention inconsistency in the staining, but ours does not have any of that. Nice and even. Aniline leather is meant to wearâlike a good pair of cowboy boots. After several days of dogs and their people, Iâve noticed it is far more scratch resistant than the brand lets on. Certainly a plus.I did not notice in the photos, but there are no buttons in the tufting. At first I was disappointed, but quickly realized this is better for a house with a puppy that takes offense to buttons lolMy only complaint is that the cushions are a little firm for my taste. Better too firm than sagging though! And I suspect they will soften with wear. This was the reason for 4 stars instead of 5.Iâll be ordering a matching ottoman (looking for the bench-style one) and likely a chair in the same color (cognac) but different style so it doesnât look overtly matched.I already had it in my head that if I didnât like this sofa when it arrived that I was going to bite the bullet and go to Pottery Barn. So glad I donât have to do that!Also, no reason to pay full price for this piece as it goes on sale from time to time. We got it during a $400 off promo.